Why Is There Anything at All? 15 Answers, Weighed

Every serious answer to philosophy's oldest question, weighed: physics, God, maths, "that's not a real question," and what's new in 2026. The weights are my judgment, because nobody can measure this.

Physics has assumptions about how the universe got going: disputed, but a dominant paradigm. It has never told you why there was anything to get going.

By Scott Covert · Last updated November 19, 2026

Scott Covert scratching his head under his bucket hat

Nobody knows, and 2026 didn't change that. What changed is the starting assumption. Since Leibniz, the default has been that nothing is the simple, natural state, and something is what needs explaining.

This year's one genuinely new argument, from the philosopher Andrew Brenner, says it may be the other way round: an empty world might be the complicated option.

In May, a public roundtable put the question to six frontier AI models. All six said existence is the default and "nothing" was never a real option. Then they agreed with each other, which is more than philosophers have managed since 1714.

What's New in 2026

Eight takes since May. Here's which are new and which are reruns.

WhenWhoSaidNew?
MayAndrew Brenner, Cambridge University Press bookA world with something in it may be simpler than an empty oneNEW
May 9Six frontier AI models (GPT-5.5, Claude Opus 4.7, Gemini 3.1 Pro, Grok 4.20, Kimi K2.6, Sonar Pro)Existence is "the default rather than something requiring an external cause"RERUN
Jun 22Sean Carroll, Mindscape podcastEmpty space has a definite, measurable energy. In other words, empty space is somethingEXPLAINER
Sep 22Stephen Meyer, The TelegraphThe universe "probably had a beginning," which points to a creatorRERUN
Sep 23Bruce Gordon, Science and Culture TodayPhysicists' "nothing" is always a physical something with lawsRERUN
Oct 2Richard Dawkins, The Telegraph"Nobody knows what came before the universe"RERUN
OctAndrew Brenner, Philosophy NowIt's a real question, and not obviously a stupid oneREBUTTAL
Nov 12Andrew Brenner, Aeon"There being something rather than nothing shouldn't surprise us if that's the simplest way for reality to be"NEW
One new argument, a lot of reruns, and physics busy as ever answering a different question: the 2026 papers argue the Big Bang was a bounce or a transition, and dark energy may be weakening (about 2 to 3 sigma, short of the 5 sigma a discovery needs). That's about how it began and how it ends. Not why.

These numbers are my bets. Nobody can measure this stuff. Only the answers that would actually end the question get a number, and those add up to 100. The ones that just push it back a step are further down. Click an answer to see what's for it and what's against it.

It Just Is

39% · there's no deeper reason

Evidence For

  • Every chain of explanation ends in something unexplained; asking for a reason for the whole may be asking for something that can't exist
  • Carroll (2018): physics allows a self-contained universe that needs nothing outside it
  • All six AI models in the May 2026 roundtable landed here

Evidence Against

  • It's not an answer, it's a stop sign
  • We accept "no reason at all" nowhere else in life or science
  • Derek Parfit: if reality turned out to be the simplest or the fullest possible, that coincidence would need explaining
Held by: Bertrand Russell (1948: "I think it is without explanation"), Sean CarrollCould evidence ever count? ARGUMENT ONLY
Is "it just is" an answer, or the polite way of saying we've stopped?

Evidence For

  • Stephen Maitzen (2012): "thing" has no criteria of its own, so the literal question is ill-formed
  • Every sensible version of it turns into an ordinary scientific question

Evidence Against

  • Brenner (Philosophy Now, Oct 2026): the question doesn't treat "nothing" as a thing; it just means "not anything"
  • "This can never be answered" has a poor record: Auguste Comte said we'd never know what stars are made of, and spectroscopy told us within decades
Held by: Stephen Maitzen, Bertrand Russell, the logical positivistsCould evidence ever count? ARGUMENT ONLY
If the question is meaningless, why does nearly everyone feel it?

Something Got Picked

20% · reality won on a feature

Evidence For

  • Brenner (2026): even an empty world would contain truths (logic, maths) that need explaining, so "it may be simpler for there to be something rather than nothing"
  • It turns the question into parts you could check: is our world the simplest possible? The fullest?
  • Parfit (1998): "Simplicity may be the higher Selector"

Evidence Against

  • Nobody knows that our world is the simplest possible
  • Brenner admits it doesn't explain why reality is this particular way
  • Parfit grants the Selector itself might be a brute fact
Held by: Derek Parfit, Andrew Brenner (2026 book, Philosophy Now, Aeon)Could evidence ever count? IN PRINCIPLE a very short final theory of physics would support it
Why would "simplest" be the rule reality follows?

Evidence For

  • One of very few answers that doesn't start by assuming something already exists

Evidence Against

  • Nobody can explain how a value makes anything happen
  • A world with this much pointless suffering is a hard sell as "required by goodness" (Parfit's objection)
Held by: John Leslie, Nicholas Rescher; historically Plato and LeibnizCould evidence ever count? ARGUMENT ONLY the world's evils count against it
How does "it would be good" get anything built?

It Couldn't Have Been Otherwise

18% · something had to exist

Evidence For

  • We rely on "everything has a reason" everywhere else
  • Alexander Pruss's modest version only needs each fact to possibly have a full explanation, and still gets there
  • Stephen Meyer (Telegraph, Sept 2026): the universe "probably had a beginning"

Evidence Against

  • David Hume: explain every part and you've explained the whole
  • Peter van Inwagen: a strict "everything has a reason" rule makes every truth necessary, which proves far too much
  • Even if granted, it doesn't say why that being made this world
  • Dawkins (Telegraph, Oct 2026): "Nobody knows what came before the universe"
Held by: Leibniz, Samuel Clarke, Alexander Pruss, Joshua Rasmussen, Stephen MeyerCould evidence ever count? ARGUMENT ONLY
What makes the necessary being necessary, and not one more brute fact with a better title?

Evidence For

  • The one physics-flavoured answer that actually removes the "might not have been"
  • Physics keeps turning out to be mathematical, all the way down so far

Evidence Against

  • Nobody can say what makes a structure physically real, or felt from the inside
  • Which structures count as "typical" is unsolved
  • Critics call it untestable
Held by: Max Tegmark, Stephen WolframCould evidence ever count? WEAKLY a non-mathematical piece of physics would count against it
What turns a structure into something that's actually there?

Everything Exists

8% · nothing was left out

Evidence For

  • No Selector, no special laws; every possibility treated the same

Evidence Against

  • The famous "incredulous stare": it adds infinitely many worlds to explain one
  • If everything happens somewhere, why is ours so orderly?
  • Unclear whether the empty world counts as one of them
Held by: David Lewis; Parfit's "All Worlds Hypothesis"Could evidence ever count? NONE POSSIBLE the other worlds can't touch ours
If every possible world exists, why is ours so tidy?

Something Nobody Has Thought Of

15%

Evidence For

  • Brenner's argument was new in 2026, after more than 300 years of people working on the question

Evidence Against

  • The known answers already cover a lot of logical ground
By definition, nobody can say.

These Push the Question Back a Step

Any of these could be true, and physics can test parts of some of them. None of them ends the question. Each one leaves a “why that?” behind, and that still needs one of the answers above. So they don’t get a number.

Physics Moved the Question

no number · answers how, not why

Evidence For

  • Real mathematical models (Vilenkin's tunnelling, Hartle and Hawking's no-boundary idea) make spacetime with no spacetime before it
  • A closed universe can have zero total energy
  • Lavrelashvili and Lehners (revised Nov 2026) tied "creation from nothing" and wormholes into one family of solutions

Evidence Against

  • The quantum "nothing" comes with fields and laws, which is quite a lot of something
  • Philosopher David Albert (NYT, 2012): the vacuum's poppings don't amount to "anything even remotely in the neighborhood of a creation from nothing"
  • Physicists Sean Carroll and Ethan Siegel agree physics doesn't answer "why anything"
Held by: Lawrence Krauss, Hawking and Mlodinow, Alexander VilenkinCould evidence ever count? ONLY FOR PARTS a model of the universe's quantum origin, not the laws behind it

Evidence For

  • Removes the single beginning that both "creation from nothing" and "it had a beginning, so God" rely on
  • Some versions make testable predictions
  • Enrique Gaztañaga's 2026 papers: the Big Bang as a bounce, possibly inside a black hole from a parent universe

Evidence Against

  • A universe that has always been there is still a universe
  • It answers "what came before?", not "why anything?"
  • Many bounces need exotic physics
Held by: Paul Steinhardt and Neil Turok, Roger Penrose, Enrique GaztañagaCould evidence ever count? ONLY FOR PARTS gravitational waves, the shape of the early sky

Evidence For

  • In quantum physics, empty states really do decay and particles really do appear
  • Wilczek calls the vacuum a material: "an ether, if ever there was one"

Evidence Against

  • An unstable state that follows laws isn't nothing. It's a very quiet something
  • It explains why there's matter, not why there are laws for the matter to obey
Held by: Frank Wilczek, Victor StengerCould evidence ever count? ONLY FOR PARTS physics can test the decay, not the why

Evidence For

  • Inflation explains real features of the cosmic microwave background
  • Many inflation models run forever into the future

Evidence Against

  • It moves the question: why is there an inflating multiverse?
  • Borde, Guth and Vilenkin (2003): inflation can't run forever into the past, so something else came first
  • Alan Guth himself: the pocket universes are "unobservable"
Held by: Alan Guth, Andrei Linde, Alexander VilenkinCould evidence ever count? ONLY FOR PARTS gravitational waves from inflation; a bubble collision in the sky

Evidence For

  • Observer selection is a real effect
  • With a multiverse, it explains why physics looks tuned for life; Dawkins leaned on it in October 2026

Evidence Against

  • It explains why we see a life-friendly universe, given that a universe exists. It's silent on why any exists
  • Many universes don't make ours more likely to be friendly (the "inverse gambler's fallacy")
Held by: Brandon Carter, John Leslie, Nick BostromCould evidence ever count? ONLY FOR PARTS a multiverse with varying constants

Mind (or a Computer) Came First

no number · the something isn't matter

Evidence For

  • The one thing nobody can doubt is that experience exists
  • Skips the hard problem of how matter produces feelings

Evidence Against

  • It changes what the something is, not why it exists: why is there mind rather than nothing?
  • Struggles to explain the stable, shared, law-following world physics describes
Held by: Bernardo Kastrup, Philip Goff (a related view), Donald Hoffman, Advaita VedantaCould evidence ever count? ARGUMENT ONLY

Evidence For

  • Nick Bostrom (2003): if civilizations run many simulations, most minds are simulated
  • David Wolpert gave the idea a formal mathematical framework (December 2025)

Evidence Against

  • It just moves the question to the simulator's universe
  • Faizal, Krauss and colleagues (2025) argue the universe can't be a simulation; that's contested (Redden, 2025)
Held by: Nick Bostrom (the argument), David Wolpert (the framework)Could evidence ever count? LOOKED, FOUND NOTHING no simulation artifacts found so far

What Could Ever Count as Evidence?

Physics can confirm or kill several of these models. Notice what it can't do.

If we found…It would helpAnswers "why anything"?
Gravitational waves from inflation in the early skyThe multiverse; some bounce models dieNo
A bubble-collision mark in the cosmic microwave backgroundThe multiverse, directlyNo
Dark energy confirmed weakening, at 5 sigmaBounces and cycles (a future crunch reopens)No
A non-computable process in natureCounts against "we're a simulation" and "the universe is maths"No
A very short final theory of physics"The simplest option won"; "the universe is maths"Partly
A proof that "everything has a reason" is true, or falseSettles brute fact against a necessary beingYes, and it's an argument, not an observation

Why "A Universe From Nothing" Annoys Philosophers

In 2012 the physicist Lawrence Krauss published A Universe from Nothing, arguing that quantum physics had cracked the question. The philosopher David Albert, reviewing it in the New York Times, was not impressed.

The problem is the word "nothing." The quantum vacuum isn't nothing. It has fields in it, and it obeys laws.

Calling the quantum vacuum "nothing" is like calling a drained swimming pool "no pool." It's empty, sure. It still has walls, a drain and plumbing, and somebody had to pour the concrete.

In this picture the walls and the plumbing are the fields and the laws. Physics has a detailed, still-argued-over story for how the water got into the pool. It has nothing to say about why there's a pool.

Sean Carroll made the same point from the physics side on his podcast in June 2026: quantum field theory says empty space has a definite energy density, a measurable constant of nature. Empty space is a thing with properties.

So the physics answers are real, and some of the best work of 2026 is in them. They answer how. The why walks out untouched every time.

Sources